Cham bin hung leng (2002) Reviews

• A Victim of Familiarity

  NIXFLIX-DOT-COM2003-08-27

  If anything, SLEEPING WITH THE DEAD is mostly the victim of familiarity aka over saturation. With a host of Hong Kong films involving dead people and people with the ability to see said dead people, SLEEPING just comes across as being more of the same. Jordan Chan gives a mature performance, but it's not enough to save a film that, simply put, is being put out in a market already filled with similar films boasting similar themes and, on most occasions, starring people who are in the same films with the same premises! Kelly Lin gives a good performance, but like Chan's turn, she's in a hapless film. There's nothing here that hasn't been done, and worst, 2002 is already bloated with films with similar themes. Maybe in another year, SLEEPING WITH THE DEAD might have been better. But alas, it's just another victim of a trend that refuses to die. (Har har.) 4 out of 10.

• semi-watchable ghost story

  dmuel2010-09-12

  Sleeping with the Dead, a nearly ten-year-old ghost story from Hong Kong, manages a few scenes to entice the viewer. But, unfortunately, there is never much of a pay-off. We see the life a doctor who becomes involved in the investigation of a series of grisly murders. Despite his job and the rash of killings, he seems detached, focused mostly on his relationship with his wife. That relationship seems to be falling apart, but the doctor has no problem attracting other women (which is odd since he's so moody), he sleeps with them but they're certainly not dead. Ghosts appear from time to time and our doctor seems to be able to see them. Ultimately the story goes nowhere. We get an explanation for the killings, and for the doctors detachment, but it falls sort of flat. Watch if you have insomnia.

• Somber and depressing story about affairs and revenge

  peternepstad2010-08-29

  Jordan Chan shacks up with the dead whenever he gets the chance in this dark ghost story about a woman who was raped and killed on her birthday and comes back to do in her assailants one by one. Simon Lui is the cop on the case, an old high school friend of Chan's, who is now a doctor. For his part, Chan seems only tenuously connected to the main story line, concerned instead with his wife, who may be having an affair, and the new girl in his life (Kelly Lin), whom he just may be falling in love with. Low budget but well scripted and well acted production with lots of atmosphere, showing there is still some life (or perhaps just undeath) in the ghost lover genre.